Find out more about our partnership opportunities today

Rising costs of home insurance

The dream of homeownership, part of the quintessential American Dream, is increasingly becoming complex for many.The past decade has seen a spiraling surge in home prices, nearly doubling according to the S&P CoreLogic Case-Shiller national index. Yet, an equally pressing – but less discussed concern – is the steep climb in home insurance premiums. This development that adds another layer of pressure for prospective and current homeowners alike.

SKYROCKETING INSURANCE PREMIUMS

In 2023, the average cost of insuring a $300,000 property saw a notable leap, increasing by 12% to reach $1,770 per year. This uptick wasn't isolated.

Analysis from S&P Global highlighted an average rate increase of 11.3% across the board. Notably, Farmers Insurance Group of Cos. and Liberty Mutual Holding Co. Inc. witnessed even more pronounced hikes, climbing by 19.4% and 17.2%, respectively.

These figures aren’t just numbers but a significant burden on homeowners, especially in states like Texas, Arizona, and Utah, which observed some of the highest rate increases.

THE DISPARITY IN HOME INSURANCE COSTS

Florida, with its heightened risk exposure to natural disasters, tops the chart as the state with the highest average annual home insurance cost. Conversely, Vermont represents the other end of the spectrum, where the limited risk of natural disasters translates into the lowest average cost.

These disparities underscore the crucial role of location in determining the cost of homeownership and the ongoing expenses associated with protecting one's home.

THE 10 LEAST AFFORDABLE STATES FOR HOME INSURANCE

When it comes to home insurance premiums, certain states stand out for their significantly higher costs.

1. Florida tops the list as the least affordable state, with average annual premiums driven by its high risk of hurricanes and other natural disasters.

2 & 3. Oklahoma and Mississippi are closely followed, and both face elevated insurance rates due to similar weather-related risks.

4 & 5. Texas and Kansas also rank high on the list, with their susceptibility to tornadoes and severe weather contributing to increased premiums.

6, 7, and 8. Georgia, Nebraska, and Massachusetts also experience higher costs, influenced by regional risk factors and market conditions.

9 & 10. Meanwhile, in New York and Colorado, dense urban areas and exposure to diverse environmental threats result in substantial home insurance expenses.

These ten states represent the most challenging regions for homeowners to secure affordable insurance coverage.

MITIGATING MEASURES & STRATEGIC CONSIDERATIONS

Homeowners facing rising insurance costs can take several proactive measures to manage and potentially reduce their expenses. Here are some key strategies:

1. Reinforce Roofs: Strengthening your roof can reduce the risk of damage during severe weather events, potentially lowering your insurance premiums.

2. Install Storm Shutters: Adding storm shutters offers additional protection against high winds and debris, which may lead to lower insurance costs.

3. Home Improvements: Other enhancements such as upgrading electrical systems, plumbing, and installing security systems can also make your home safer and more resilient, resulting in insurance savings.

4. Shop Around for Insurance: Regularly comparing insurance quotes from different providers can help you find the best rates and coverage options.

5. Bundle Policies: Combining home insurance with other policies, like auto insurance, often results in discounts.

6. Increase Deductibles: Opting for a higher deductible can lower your premium, although it means more out-of-pocket costs in the event of a claim.

Despite these strategies, one significant challenge remains: fewer coverage options are available in high-risk areas. Potential buyers should consider selecting a property in a low-risk area. Buyers can secure more favorable insurance rates and broader coverage options by choosing locations less prone to natural disasters. 

 


The trajectory of home insurance costs and its implications for homeownership affordability raises critical questions about the long-term sustainability of current trends. With insurers recalibrating their offerings in light of increased risks – from natural disasters to construction costs – home insurance is undoubtedly evolving. Prospective homebuyers must, therefore, have a nuanced understanding of insurance dynamics as part of their homeownership planning.

Navigating the challenges of rising home insurance costs requires a multifaceted approach. From understanding geographic differences to employing mitigation strategies and considering long-term sustainability, homeowners and prospective buyers must arm themselves with information and strategic insights. As the industry continues to shift, staying informed and adaptable will be key to managing the changing homeownership market.

If you need help finding the best homeowners insurance coverage for the best price, speak to a SimplyIOA agent at 833.872.4467 or get a homeowners insurance quote online now.

share this post